Relay
Signal Review

How we compare residential proxy detection tools

All 36 criteria and six category weights are published. The framework emphasizes residential coverage, legitimate-user handling and useful evidence beyond network ownership.

Which products belong in this comparison?

The ten-product comparison covers observed residential-proxy intelligence, live device/network checks, broader fraud platforms and managed traffic protection. A review identifies the evidence layer and required integration rather than presenting every product as the same kind of API.

The framework favors residential-proxy coverage with non-IP corroboration and practical fraud context. A lower overall score for an IP database is not a claim that it is weaker at local IP enrichment. Use the alternatives by deployment to match the product to the job.

Considered but not included

Free-only static IP lists, datacenter-only proxy checks, VPN-only checkers and general WAF rules without residential-proxy evidence do not meet the comparison’s residential scope. Basic ASN or geolocation coverage alone is insufficient. Managed protection is included where its documented approach addresses residential traffic.

Scoring rubric: 36 criteria in six categories

Criteria use a 0–10 editorial assessment scale. The original relative weights total 98 units; the normalized shares below show each category’s contribution as its assessment multiplied by its weight divided by 98.

All 36 criteria, six original relative weights and their normalized shares.
CategoryRelative weight / shareCriteria scored
Residential-proxy detection quality7 criteria26 of 98
26.53 percent
a dedicated residential-proxy verdict that separates a proxy exit from an ordinary household user in both directions; recall on clean residential exits that pass ASN, hostname, and datacenter checks; mobile and carrier proxy recall; coverage of ISP proxies, SOCKS nodes on infected hosts, and SDK-monetized devices; classifying how an IP is used rather than only who owns it; direct observation of exits over ASN, WHOIS, or rDNS inference; and secondary coverage of VPN, datacenter, Tor, hosting, and private relay traffic.
False-positive control on lookalike networks5 criteria18 of 98
18.37 percent
carrier-grade NAT and mobile carrier NAT; university, hotel, and public-network egress; corporate VPN egress and Apple Private Relay; confidence-graded handling, so a low-confidence hit is not blocked automatically; and separating anonymization from actual abuse.
Non-IP corroboration and fraud context6 criteria16 of 98
16.33 percent
client-side checks of the WebRTC-exposed local IP, timezone, and locale against the claimed address; round-trip latency versus the claimed location; TLS and HTTP/2 connection fingerprints; a device identity that persists across rotating exits; behavioral and session velocity; and fraud context beyond proxy status, such as automation, multi-accounting, and account takeover.
Freshness and rotation handling5 criteria14 of 98
14.29 percent
update cadence, with live observation ahead of daily list refreshes; exposed recency fields such as last seen and percent of days seen; how fast a newly observed exit reaches the verdict; reputation that decays once an address leaves a proxy pool; and proprietary observation versus a resold third-party list.
Verdict depth, transparency, and evidence6 criteria12 of 98
12.24 percent
a graded score or confidence instead of a bare proxy:true; named reasons behind each verdict; proxy-network attribution and connection type; ASN, ISP, and geolocation enrichment; documented methodology and confidence bands; and accuracy claims tied to a stated test set rather than marketing copy.
Integration, latency, and commercial access7 criteria12 of 98
12.24 percent
a production API with a documented, predictable JSON schema; client and server SDKs, webhooks, and bulk lookup; deployment shape across inline edge, API at decision points, and offline dataset; time to verdict at signup, login, and checkout; reliability and rate limits under burst traffic; self-serve access with transparent public pricing; and a free tier large enough to benchmark, plus unit cost at production volume.

Evidence quality resolves otherwise equivalent candidates. It is not an extra two-point category or a 37th criterion. Editor’s Choice does not add points. Overall scores express editorial product fit; they are not customer-review averages or detection-accuracy percentages.

A criterion is a question applied consistently across the products, not a guarantee that every product satisfies it. Reviews describe the current output, feature entitlement and integration required.

What counts as evidence?

Official product pages establish capability and scope. Documentation establishes fields, observation windows and integration requirements. Current pricing establishes the plan, billing unit and period. Vendor articles add mechanism and implementation context; sources identify their purpose and the date read.

Distinguish ISP ownership from observed proxy participation, a connection indicator from an abuse finding and live session output from a historical IP lookup. Read older technical guides as explanations of an approach, not current product-wide benchmarks.

When sources differ, use the current page appropriate to the fact: the pricing page for a current offer, the API reference for a field or observation window. A public checker does not establish API quotas. A free geolocation tier does not establish residential-proxy entitlement.

A useful residential-proxy evaluation protocol

  1. Define the protected action and the question being evaluated: proxy classification, account abuse or the application response.
  2. Use independently known ordinary sessions and authorized controlled proxy sessions.
  3. Include shared homes, mobile carrier NAT, corporate egress and privacy relays.
  4. Vary stable and rotating exits while preserving known account/device relationships.
  5. Record the exact product, plan, settings, collection state and observation/database version.
  6. Measure returned signals, missing data, collection/lookup/decision time and actual restrictions separately.
  7. Investigate unresolved cases and compare the required feature, billing unit and complete operating cost.

Do not use the detector’s own flag as the ground-truth label. An appeal is a case to investigate, not automatically a false positive. Read the evaluation guide and shared-network guide.

How to read a figure on this site

Notation and evidence context, checked October 21, 2026.
MarkingMeaning
Published valueA value on the linked vendor page or documentation, read on the stated date.
Confirm access / request quoteThe required current plan, allowance or deployment terms need confirmation. It is not a zero or an estimated price.
Editorial scoreA 0–10 assessment under this framework, separate from customer ratings and measured accuracy.
Different products or windowsCompare each result within its documented field definition, observation period and integration.

Editorial standards

Pages are produced and maintained by the publication’s editorial team, with Lena Fischer credited as author. Sources are linked so readers can inspect the evidence behind product facts and compare the relevant deployment conditions.

Zero paid placements

Providers cannot buy a score, ranking position or Editor’s Choice. We do not accept sponsored reviews, paid placement or backlink trades as conditions for coverage or corrections. A vendor link alone does not establish an affiliate arrangement.

The About page explains the mission, author and distinction between an award and a score. Terms of Use describes the publication’s scope.

Corrections

Send the page URL, passage and a current supporting source through Contact. Identify the exact product, field, observation period, plan, billing unit or integration condition. Corrections are assessed on evidence without a payment, placement or backlink condition.

Reviews using this framework

Summarize this page with